Advanced update process

This is an advanced version of the standard update process.

Managing migration steps

When you run into problems running the nx migrate --run-migrations command, here are some solutions to break the process down into manageable steps.

Make changes easier to review by committing after each migration runs

Depending on the size of the update (e.g. migrating between major versions is likely to require more significant changes than migrating between feature releases), and the size of the workspace, the overall nx migrate process may generate a lot of changes which then need to be reviewed. Particularly if there are then manual changes which need to be made in addition to those made by nx migrate, it can make the associated PR harder to review because of not being able to distinguish between what was changed automatically and what was changed manually.

If you pass --create-commits to the --run-migrations command, Nx will automatically create a dedicated commit for each successfully completed migration, for example:

nx migrate --run-migrations --create-commits

Your git history will then look something like the following:

Terminal

~/workspace❯

nx migrate --run-migrations --create-commits

git log commit 8c862c780106ab8736985c01de1477309a403548 Author: YOUR_GIT_USERNAME <your_git_email@example.com> Date: Thu Apr 14 18:35:44 2022 +0400 chore: [nx migration] name-of-the-second-migration-which-ran commit eb83bca97927af26aae731a2cf51ad62cc75efa3 Author: YOUR_GIT_USERNAME <your_git_email@example.com> Date: Thu Apr 14 18:35:44 2022 +0400 chore: [nx migration] name-of-the-first-migration-which-ran etc

By default, nx will apply the prefix of chore: [nx migration] to each commit in order to clearly identify it, but you can also customize this prefix by passing --commit-prefix to the command:

nx migrate --run-migrations --create-commits --commit-prefix="chore(core): AUTOMATED - "
commit 8c862c780106ab8736985c01de1477309a403548 Author: YOUR_GIT_USERNAME <your_git_email@example.com> Date: Thu Apr 14 18:35:44 2022 +0400 chore(core): AUTOMATED - name-of-the-second-migration-which-ran commit eb83bca97927af26aae731a2cf51ad62cc75efa3 Author: YOUR_GIT_USERNAME <your_git_email@example.com> Date: Thu Apr 14 18:35:44 2022 +0400 chore(core): AUTOMATED - name-of-the-first-migration-which-ran etc

Customizing which migrations run by altering migrations.json

For small projects, running all the migrations at once often succeeds without any issues. For large projects, more flexibility is sometimes needed, and this is where having the separation between generating the migrations to be run, and actually running them, really shines.

All you need to do is amend the JSON file in whatever way makes sense based on your circumstances, for example:

  • You may have to skip a migration.
  • You may want to run one migration at a time to address minor issues.
  • You may want to reorder migrations.
  • You may want to run the same migration multiple time if the process takes a long time and you had to rebase.

Because you can run nx migrate --run-migrations as many times as you want, you can achieve all of that by commenting out and reordering items in migrations.json. The migration process can take a long time, depending on the number of migrations, so it is useful to commit the migrations file with the partially-updated repo alongside any changes which were created by previously completed migrations.

You can even provide a custom location for the migrations file if you wish, you simply pass it to the --run-migrations option:

nx migrate --run-migrations=migrations.json

Choosing optional package updates to apply

While in most cases you want to be up to date with Nx and the dependencies it manages, sometimes you might need to stay on an older version of such a dependency. For example, you might want to update Nx to the latest version but keep Jest on v27.x.x and not update it to v28.x.x. For such scenarios, nx migrate allows you to choose what to update using the --interactive flag.

Optional package updates

You can't choose to skip any arbitrary package update. To ensure that a plugin works well with older versions of a given package, the plugin must support it. Therefore, Nx plugin authors define what package updates are optional.

Taking control of package updates

While opting out of applying some package updates is supported by Nx, please keep in mind that you are effectively taking control of those package updates and opting out of Nx managing them. This means you'll need to keep up with the version requirements for those packages and those that depend on them. You'll also need to consider more things when updating them at some point as explained later.

Interactively opting out of package updates

To opt out of package updates, you need to run the migration in interactive mode:

nx migrate latest --interactive

As the migration runs and collects the package updates, you'll be prompted to apply optional package updates, and you can choose what to do based on your needs. The package.json will be updated and the migrations.json will be generated considering your responses to those prompts.

Updating dependencies that are behind the versions Nx manages

Once you have skipped some optional updates, there'll come a time when you'll want to update those packages. To do so, you'll need to generate the package updates and migrations from the Nx version that contained those skipped updates.

Say you skipped updating Jest to v28.x.x. That package update was meant to happen as part of the @nrwl/jest@14.6.0 update, but you decided to skip it at the time. The nx migrate command collects updates for a package from versions higher than the currently installed version of the said package in the workspace. Since you need to collect updates and migrations that were meant to happen for version 14.6.0 (a version older that what's currently installed), you need to run the command and "fake" the installed version of the @nrwl/jest package to a version lower than 14.6.0:

nx migrate @nrwl/jest@latest --from=@nrwl/jest@14.5.0

The above command will effectively collect any package update and migration meant to run if your workspace had @nrwl/jest@14.5.0 installed. While collecting package updates and migrations for a specific package works, it's not always the best way to proceed.

In the specific example we have been using, since you manage the jest package (because you opted out of its automated migrations), you also need to be mindful of packages that depend on it and act accordingly. You could have different version requirements from different packages that depend on it. An example would be if you decide to stay on Jest v27 while updating your Angular version to v15. The jest-preset-angular package doesn't have a version that works with both. All versions of jest-preset-angular that support Angular v15 require Jest v28.

In that case you have a couple of options:

  • Don't update to Angular v15
  • Update Jest to v28 and Angular to v15

If you choose the latter, you'll need to make sure package updates and migrations from @nrwl/jest (manages jest) and @nrwl/angular (manages jest-preset-angular) are collected. You can do that by using the nx package that groups the rest of the first-party Nx plugins:

nx migrate latest --from=nx@14.5.0
Collect updates for all packages

As a general rule, prefer to run nx migrate latest --from=nx@<version> so package updates and migrations are collected from all Nx first-party plugins. By doing so, you'll be closer to what a fully-automated Nx migration does and avoid some potential issues. While it might collect migrations previously run in the repo, those migrations should be idempotent and you could always remove them from the migrations.json file if you want.

Other advanced capabilities

Overriding versions

Sometimes, you may want to use a different version of a package than what Nx recommends. To do that, specify the package and version:

nx migrate latest --to="jest@22.0.0,cypress@3.4.0"

By default, Nx uses currently installed packages to calculate what migrations need to run. To override them, override the version:

nx migrate latest --to="@nrwl/jest@12.0.0"
Overriding versions

By choosing a version different of what Nx recommend you might use a package version that might have not been tested for a given Nx version. This might lead to unexpected issues.

Reverting a failed update

Updates are best done on a clean git history so that it can be easily reversed if something fails. We try our best to make sure migrations do not fail but if one does, please report it on GitHub.

If an update fails for any reason, you can revert it as you do any other set of changes:

git reset --hard # Reset any changes git clean -fd # Delete newly added files and directories
--create-commits

If using --create-commits, you will need to first retrieve the SHA of the commit before your first automated migration commit in order to jump back to the point before the migrations ran, e.g. git reset --hard YOUR_APPROPRIATE_SHA_HERE)

Recommendations

One major version at a time, small steps

Migrating Jest, Cypress, ESLint, React, Angular, Next, and more is a difficult task. All the tools change at different rates, they can conflict with each other. In addition, every workspace is different. Even though our goal is for you to update any version of Nx to a newer version of Nx in a single go, sometimes it doesn't work. The following process is better for large workspaces.

Say you want to migrate from Nx 10.1.0 to Nx 11.0.1. The following steps are more likely to work comparing to nx migrate 11.0.1.

  • Run nx migrate 10.4.5 to update the latest version in the 10.x branch.
  • Run nx migrate --run-migrations.
  • Next, run nx migrate 11.0.1.
  • Run nx migrate --run-migrations.

Reference